Stone Old Guardian
Barley Wine
2004 RELEASE

~ Initial Tasting ~
February 10, 2004
Click on a photo for Tasting Notes


Steve Wagner
President & Brewmaster

Lee Chase
Head Brewer

Greg Koch
Chairman & CEO

Chris Cochran
Marketing & Promotions

Arlan Arnsten
Vice President of Sales

Toshi Ishii
COO & Brewery Director
Yo-Ho Brewing




Steve Wagner

President & Brewmaster
Appearance:
Clear and golden-hued.
Aroma:
Big, resiny hop aroma dominates.
Flavor:
Strong bitterness with complex, dry malt flavors --- alcohol!
Palate:
Full-bodied, low but appropriate carbonation level.
Overall:
Give it time!




Lee Chase

Head Brewer
Appearance:
Light and clear in first pour, but a little hazy as the bottle ended. Our lightest colored Old Guardian yet...pale and understated appearance (like W.S. Burrows)
Aroma:
Sweet aroma with some significant hops and a little malt, with an indescribable fruitiness (yeast).
Flavor:
A big hop and alcohol sweetness (alcohol comes across as sweet) with not a whole lot of malt character upfront.
Palate:
Fairly light and quire drinkable - aside from the fact that it is over 10% ABV! I didn't get much of the metallicness that others were getting from this tasting, but I did get a little of the saltiness.
Overall:
Young but pretty enjoyable -- I'm sure it will et less hoppy & a little more malty with age. I don't know if I like the fact that the hops will fade, but I look forward to the experience...




Greg Koch

Chairman & CEO
Appearance:
Bright, clear and light orangey color.
Aroma:
Pear? Modest alcohol with muted malt notes. Some hop aromas, but mostly fruity notes (white raisin).
Flavor:
Pow baby! Arlan mentioned some scotch late back notes, I agree. Islay I think, but without peat. Ocean salty notes, often characterized in a great single malt, are also present in the back --- almost more noticeable a minute or more after the last sip.
Palate:
Quite dry considering it's a barley wine. Not really a "to style" barley wine, but hey, who in the hell cares --- it's tasty! Some metallic notes that will hopefully mellow...currently reminiscent of touching an almost-dead 9volt to your tongue.
Overall:
Swirling some of the yeast from the bottle's bottom and adding it to my glass softens the mouthfeel a bit, but it's still pretty aggressive. Arlan thinks it's a bit astringent, I don't agree. "Dry," yes, but not astringent. I like it. Will benefit from a little time in the bottle. I prefer the 2003 recipe better, but then I thought it was brilliant from day one. This one I am certain will grow on me and it will go from "woah" to "hell yeah!"




Chris Cochran

Marketing & Promotions
Appearance:
Clear, golden-straw color...maybe a tad towards amber with a nice head retention (CO2 levels seem OK).
Aroma:
Abundant hop aroma with a minutia of malt (this isn't your Dad's O.G.!) that seems to be more pronounced as it wamed.
Flavor:
Warming effect right away = alcohol. Rather dry, crisp malt/alcohol notes...especially as it warms up.
Palate:
Big mouthfeel, carbonation seemed to diminish after initial pour. Smooth. Alcohol complexities everywhere!
Overall:
Not the usual Old Guardian suspect - in a good way. This baby's going to age nicely...pull up a chair.



Arlan Arnsten
Vice President of Sales
Appearance:
Light amber and crystal clear - although it is bottle conditioned and it did become a little cloudy after the bottom of the bottle was added. A nice white lacey head, but very light color for a Barley Wine.
Aroma:
Low malt but evident big hop aroma. The "warmth" eminates up even though it has been stored cold!
Flavor:
Definitely not like the previous Old Guardians Hops and alcohol - the malt comes after a little warming. Subtle and soft malt begins to balance this concoction. Yeast adds the citrus character O.G. is known for.
Palate:
Dry and big. Scotch-like and very unique. The yeast add roundness to the body - I recommend a "yeasty" taste.
Overall:
It's a bit young - hold on to this one for a while. The time aged blending will certainly produce a timeless classic.




Toshi Ishii

COO & Brewery Director
Yo-Ho Brewing
Appearance:
Super clear for bottle conditioned. Medium amber color.
Aroma:
[Japanese]
Flavor:
[Japanese]
Palate:
[Japanese]
Overall:
[Japanese]